Subject: Is there any point in reporting traffic incidents?

About Cyclist Awareness and Cycling Safety Forum:
Learn and share tips, feedback and experiences on what can be done to make the roads safer for cyclists and cyclists to ride safer.
You are not logged-in, Please Login

Is there any point in reporting traffic incidents?

Posted on: 31st May 2019 7:36 PM    Quote and Reply


Quote:
"Formerly posted by Bluesky3000: Singapore roads are very dangerous for cyclist as drivers here generally hate or have no regards for cyclist. So please install and invest in a cam back and front. "
I no longer cycle to work, and/or during my work. So I can choose to avoid the day, place, time, with more motorised traffic around. I cycle to keep fit, and some places/route with lesser traffic than PCN (not even e-bike/e-scooter). 

Regular Forumer
6,172 posts
Forum Rep: 42

Singapore
Posted on: 31st May 2019 6:50 PM    Quote and Reply


Singapore roads are very dangerous for cyclist as drivers here generally hate or have no regards for cyclist. So please install and invest in a cam back and front. 

Regular Forumer
24 posts
Forum Rep: 2


Posted on: 31st May 2019 11:27 AM    Quote and Reply


Quote:
"Formerly posted by csk1975: I currently commute daily to work in Singapore - unfortunately I have no choice but to ride 3-4kms on the road - the rest is on bike paths. I have multiple very bright flashing lights, a horn, a mirror and have ridden 10 of thousands of kms in many cities so have good road sense. But the drivers here scare me.

Today whilst riding past Marina Bay Sands a driver in a van deliberately tried to knock me over. Even though the road is 3 lanes wide, the driver didn't change lanes, he tailed me closely along Bayfront Ave trying to force me into the gutter whilst I was riding at ~35kmh, at the casino exit a taxi was half blocking the far left lane which forced the van driver to move into the middle lane. He then accelerated level with me and once level he turned hard left into the underground carpark entrance just after the casino exit and before the bus stop and ERP gantry. I understood his intentions and hit my brakes before he did this and I was able to narrowly miss the side of the van as I also turned into the entrance to avoid the collision. A casino security guard/traffic warden rushed over to see if I was ok, it was obviously very close.

There is no doubt that the driver did this intentionally. He accelerated level with me, he looked over his shoulder at me before he turned - this is why I had already hit my brakes before he turned - I could see what he was trying to do, and even though I hit my very loud horn as I braked and turned he just continued to turn and try and hit me.

In hindsight I should have just pulled into the first taxi entrance and onto the footpath - and not even got close to this driver. But as a vulnerable road user who follows the road rules and tries my level best to be visible, predictable and defensive I did not expect someone to use their vehicle as a weapon.

My question is - is it worth reporting this? If the driver's actions did not result in a crash and/or death or serious injury are the traffic police interested? Do reports about this sort of dangerous driving ever result in action being taken?

The thing is people who do these sorts of things don't do them in isolation, they are usually habitual in their actions. Maybe the next cyclist he tries to hit won't be able to avoid him."
A taxi did the same to me. Taxi driver's confessed alibi was that my road biek acceleration so fast about to undertake his taxi. This is unacceptable to him being undertaken by a bicycle. I called the Police to him from fleeing. The TP pretended could not find the accident location. The ambulance had to wait for almost 30 minutes for the TP to show up. Always make accident report. We never know what alibi they can give in their police report. In the event we need to make a claim, we have lodged police report for documentation.

Regular Forumer
6,172 posts
Forum Rep: 42

Singapore
Posted on: 22nd Nov 2018 3:54 PM    Quote and Reply


Hi!
I know this post is very old - hope you are still safe commuting on the roads here! Just wanted to show my support for this. As a bicycle commuter myself, I unforutnately face such situations repeatedly. I will report them to the police/LTA (and as mentioned by other commenters, the respective company if it is a company vehicle). So far, nothing has ever come out of this. 
I nonetheless would encourage you to keep doing it, because there is no point in giving up on the least we as cyclists can do to improve the situation: making our voices heard!
Sadly, almost 8 years later, not much seems to have changed with regards to this. 

Freshie Forumer
1 posts
Forum Rep: 0

Singapore
Posted on: 29th May 2011 12:48 AM    Quote and Reply


If you really feel that he did it on purpose, I think it'll be good to report him, even tho the police will not/cannot do anything to him now. But that's only help if you have his license plate number.

Your report might be able to contribute to the police investigation, if he hit some cyclist in the future and trying to deny and push the blame to the cyclist. Since this is not the first police record, the police might be able to see that the accident might actually be a motive attempt to knock a cyclist down. 

Regular Forumer
18 posts
Forum Rep: 0

Singapore
Riding:
Posted on: 27th May 2011 12:47 AM        

I currently commute daily to work in Singapore - unfortunately I have no choice but to ride 3-4kms on the road - the rest is on bike paths. I have multiple very bright flashing lights, a horn, a mirror and have ridden 10 of thousands of kms in many cities so have good road sense. But the drivers here scare me.

Today whilst riding past Marina Bay Sands a driver in a van deliberately tried to knock me over. Even though the road is 3 lanes wide, the driver didn't change lanes, he tailed me closely along Bayfront Ave trying to force me into the gutter whilst I was riding at ~35kmh, at the casino exit a taxi was half blocking the far left lane which forced the van driver to move into the middle lane. He then accelerated level with me and once level he turned hard left into the underground carpark entrance just after the casino exit and before the bus stop and ERP gantry. I understood his intentions and hit my brakes before he did this and I was able to narrowly miss the side of the van as I also turned into the entrance to avoid the collision. A casino security guard/traffic warden rushed over to see if I was ok, it was obviously very close.

There is no doubt that the driver did this intentionally. He accelerated level with me, he looked over his shoulder at me before he turned - this is why I had already hit my brakes before he turned - I could see what he was trying to do, and even though I hit my very loud horn as I braked and turned he just continued to turn and try and hit me.

In hindsight I should have just pulled into the first taxi entrance and onto the footpath - and not even got close to this driver. But as a vulnerable road user who follows the road rules and tries my level best to be visible, predictable and defensive I did not expect someone to use their vehicle as a weapon.

My question is - is it worth reporting this? If the driver's actions did not result in a crash and/or death or serious injury are the traffic police interested? Do reports about this sort of dangerous driving ever result in action being taken?

The thing is people who do these sorts of things don't do them in isolation, they are usually habitual in their actions. Maybe the next cyclist he tries to hit won't be able to avoid him.
csk1975
27th May 2011
From: Singapore
Show earlier posts
Login to see your Forum Rankings