• Home
  • News
  • Articles
  • Rides
  • Events
  • Forum
  • Reviews
  • New Bikes
    • New Bike Parts
    • New Promos & News
    • Togoparts Store
  • Marketplace
  • Bikeshops
    • Singapore Listing
    • Malaysia Listing
  • Showrooms
  • My Togoparts
    • Privi Membership
    • Add Tcredits
    • Members
    • Invite Friends
    • Approve Friends
    • My Friends
Login Togoparts!    userID: Password: New? Join Togoparts! Forgot your Password?
   Launch PM 

Country:

States/Region/District:

City/Town:

Advertisement
NewsHarsher penalties on errant drivers as deterrence?
Harsher penalties on errant drivers as deterrence?
Dean Koh - 1st Feb 2013

Would imposing tougher punishments on errant drivers really reduce speeding and related accidents?

According to a news report by Today Online, Second Minister for Home Affairs S Iswaran said that harsher penalties for errant drivers and more speed cameras and Traffic Police officers on the roads are among the measures the authorities are mulling over to improve road safety.

Mr Iswaran's comments come after the tragic accident in Tampines on Monday involving a cement truck left two boys dead, sparking renewed calls from the public and as well as relevant bodies like the Singapore Cycling Federation to improve safety on the roads.

While it may be, at least in the short term, feasible to improve stiffer penalties to deter errant drivers from speeding and resulting in accidents, the bigger question is the treatment of cyclists on the roads, as well as the type of punishments irresponsible drivers will get for causing the deaths of cyclists. Many cyclists are very unhappy that these drivers ‘get away' with fines or even just a few months of jail for their crime.

Part of the problem also lies in drivers' perceptions of cyclists as ‘nuisances' on the roads and having very little or no regard for them when driving behind or alongside them. I'm not saying all drivers are like that but definitely much more can be done to accommodate and make cyclists feel inclusive on the roads. Cyclists, too, have to abide by traffic rules and not as if they own the roads but it is shared with other users.

My take is, no matter how many millions we spend on cycling infrastructure or meting out harsher punishments for errant motorists, it is ultimately futile if the various stakeholders or those who share the road do not attempt to understand each other or respect each other.

Let's respect each other on the roads and spare a thought for one another. At the end of the day, whether you are cyclist or motorist, you want to make it home safely to your family, friends and loved ones.

Original article that this commentary is based on:

http://www.todayonline.com/singapore/errant-drivers-could-face-harsher-penalties

Photo: © Jean Guichard/Sygma/Corbis

Have your say
 >It is usually an orchestrated chaos, yet still all seems to flow perfectly with minimal road kills.

You know anecdotes are all well and good, but the actual road statistics beg to differ:-

a en.wikipedia.org link

Philippines 20.0 606.1
Singapore 4.8 30.4

The first column is road deaths per 100,000 inhabitants, the second per 100,000 vehicles. Obviously the first column is very much affected by car ownership rates. But the second column suggest the Philippines has 20 times more deaths per vehicle than Singapore.

Not that I am saying Singapore is even close to first world country rates. The only reason Singapore has a low fatality rate per 100,000 inhabitants is due to the low car ownership rate, 7-8 deaths per 100,000 vehicles is normal for first world countries apart from the USA which has carmageddon:-

Australia 5.71 8
Germany 4.5 7.2
Japan 3.85 6.8
Netherlands 4.1 7
United Kingdom 3.59 7

United States of America 12.3 15
- csk1975 , Singapore. 1st Feb 2013 6:11 PM
 Ah, in my country the Philippines, you kill a person while driving and it is found to be your fault, you get a jail term. I mean come on, this is a life taken. I dunno how they term that criminal offense there. I think it maybe homicide due to reckless negligence or something like that.killing someone and just getting a fine is a laughable penalty. I mean, what is this, " Deathrace 2013"? Please lah, how to deter such irresponsible actions? Light sentences is just like your Mom pinching you when young after a naughty action. So in the end, you'd do it again cause that pinch is bearable anyway....Ever see drivers yack at their hand phones while driving hazardously fast? Or , impatient motorists doing a left turn trying to get a fast opportunity to speed off while pedestrians are still crossing on a green man signal? No one spank these kids, kids think that this is okay. Point is, no precedent punishment, dangerous action never will abate nor controlled.Anyone here ever drove on high density traffic like Thailand, Indonesia or the Philipines? Well, as an example, I drive in the Philippines and mind me saying that drivers there are like Starwars alliance and empire fighters doing a dogfight. It is usually an orchestrated chaos, yet still all seems to flow perfectly with minimal road kills. Of course there are road deaths, but frankly speaking if we are to talk ratios here, Sg seems to be way ahead in terms of traffic density contra road accidents.what am I trying to imply here, we'll Philippine motorists are aware that being the culprit of a motor accident causing death may eventually land you at least 10 years in jail minimum and depending on judicial consideration, this aside compensating the family of the aggrieved. Now, if that is not detterent enough, I don't know what other method may workout. But least to say here, imposing a measly fine just does not solve the issue of motor driving recklessness.....I mean, as an example say 7 months fine and A public apology would'nt change anything except for a life that has been snuffed out due to someone's irresponsibility.Think about it. Sg maybe a first world country, but laws like this is seriously laughable and unfair and reeks 3rd world.                Ask yourself this question, ....what if the victim was a family member? The guilty party no matter how sincerely they apologize will never bring your loved one' s life back.Need to change the law into something more realistic. They should do it now to save more lives. 
- hamsterchick , Sembawang, Singapore. 1st Feb 2013 4:30 PM
 Will work meh? One short trip during lunch to a bike shop in Hougang Ave 7 witness 1 driver who speed up when the light turn ember (she is at least 20m away from the traffic light), she come to an E brake over the stop line and has to reverse back and of coz, she DID SO WITHOUT CHECKING HER REAR. Take a few shout for her to wake up.And the nice driver who muscle his way thru a pedestrian crossing (TURN LEFT ON RED, light in favor of pesdestrian) near Hougang Interchange...Speaking of bike shop...I need new hubs...which bike shop have READY stock for Chris King Hub in Black or Pink or XTR 985 Hub??
- Meowfifa , Singapore. 1st Feb 2013 1:59 PM
 The judicial system in Singapore makes no sense to me. You can be hanged for selling Marjuauna, or jailed for smoking it, but if you kill a motorcyclist or cyclist on the road, you get a fine? White collar criminals get longer jail sentances for embezzeling funds than an employer who tortured her maid? What does this say about Singapore's values as a society? Smoking a joint is a more serious crime than killing someone? Stealing money is a more serious crime than torturing and abusing another person? Seems a bit upside down to me.
- motomuppet , Singapore. 1st Feb 2013 1:45 PM
See all 5 Responses
Login to Post Comment
Latest News
Eurobike 2013: 40,000 Trade Visitors from 100 Countries Expected
The 22nd Eurobike, the international bicycle trade show, takes place in Friedrichshafen from...
ORICA-GreenEDGE unveil their Tour de France Nine
Ironman legend Cameron Brown heads up Pro-field for MetaMan Bintan
Blanco's pre-selection for the Tour de France: 13 riders
Singapore: Tampines cycling path network ready to roll
Eric Sheppard finishes on podium for second straight day, caps off superb Tour de Korea for OCBC Singapore Pro Cycling Team
Eric Sheppard captures second place at Tour de Korea for OCBC Singapore Pro Cycling Team's sixth podium finish this season
Thomas Rabou narrowly misses out on podium finish, soars up General Classification at Tour de Korea
Slovenia: Svein Tuft Scores 20th Win of the Season for ORICA-GreenEDGE
OCBC Singapore Pro Cycling Team's strong performance in team time trial launches Sheppard up Best Young Rider standings
Sheppard, Rabou keep pace with leaders at Tour de Korea to stay in top 10 of General Classification
Japan: Underground Bicycle Parking Systems (video)
Read all...
Search News
Tools
  • Togoparts Articles
  • Find a New Bikes or Parts
  • Buy & Sell Used Bikes
  • Read User Reviews

Home  .  Terms of Service  .  Privacy Policy  .  About  .  Jobs - We're Hiring!  .  Advertise  .  Feedback  .  FAQ Become a fan! Follow us on Twitter All times are GMT +8 Hours 
Togoparts.com is the number one bicycle portal in Singapore featuring classifieds marketplace for buying and selling Mountain Bikes, MTB, Road Bikes, Tri Bikes, Time Trial Bikes, Folding Bikes, Recumbent Bikes, Singlespeed Bikes, Tandem Bikes. Find useful bike products and services information like Suspensions Forks, Wheels, Frames, Brakes, Handlebars, Pedals, Stems, Seatposts, Jerseys and Accessories. Read consumer reviews, in-depth bike product reviews and event coverages.
PortalConnect network - Togoparts.com . Copyright© 2001-2013 Togoparts.com
All Rights Reserved.